By Howard Deevers

 

From the first days of my aviation training, I stumbled into this debate about aircraft types: Is a high-wing airplane better, or is a low-wing airplane better? I remember some of those “debates” becoming almost shouting matches. There were pilots who were absolutely convinced that a low-wing plane is better than a high-wing plane, and other pilots who were equally convinced of the opposite. To be sure, there are some aerodynamic differences in the designs, but it is a subject to discuss over coffee at the clubhouse, not in a shouting match. The discussion will not likely change anyone’s mind on the subject.

If you look back at the beginning of aviation, all planes had two wings: one high wing and one low wing. The reason for that? The innovators believed that they got more lift from two wings. It was not until WWI, when more experimentation began, that monoplanes started to appear. Biplanes did not go out of style right away. Even Richard Bach wrote a book about biplanes. There are still a lot of biplanes flying. Stearman still has an annual fly-in event that lasts a week in Galesburg, IL.

Over time, physics and engineering replaced experimentation and guesswork, and now all planes are engineered for efficiency. So why do we still have this “debate” today? To be sure, there are some aerodynamic differences between high-wing and low-wing airplanes. First of all, you’ll notice that airplanes look different. You can have a Cessna 172 sitting next to a Piper Archer on a ramp and know immediately that they are different airplanes. The high-wing Cessna 172 offers a better view of the ground than the low-wing airplane. Is that worth a debate? The Cessna 172 has two doors and is easier to get into and out of than the low-wing Piper. You have to enter and exit the low-wing Piper through only one door and climb on the wing to do it. Is that worth a debate? Maybe. The other issue I hear about often is the difference in “ground effect” between high-wing and low-wing airplanes. That could be the subject of some debate, but certainly not a “shouting match.” Two aeronautical engineers could probably spend a whole day discussing “ground effect” on airplanes.

In my years of flying both kinds of airplanes, I noticed one advantage that the high-wing airplane had over the low-wing airplane: I could stand under the wing of the Cessna 172 and tie it down after a flight without getting wet in the rain. Not so with the Piper low-wing airplanes. And, yes, I have flown both types in wet weather.

As aviation has advanced so much over the decades, there are many other subjects that may be worthy of debate, but I find it interesting that this high-wing vs. low-wing subject is still around. Maybe not as much as it was years ago, but it is still around. In the end, I think it comes down to personal preference and not so much to technical engineering and design. Now most of the discussions I hear are about what kind of electronics to put in the panel!

Want to know more about aircraft design and safety features? Come to an FAA Safety Wings seminar sponsored by your ARIZONA PILOTS ASSOCIATION. They are free. Check out the website for a location and time near you. And “don’t forget to bring your wingman.”

Please login to add a comment.